About this document

This is a prototype of an automatic report that documents how the user specified the operating model and their various justifications.


Introduction

  1. Describe the history and current status of the fishery, including fleets, sectors, vessel types and practices/gear by vessel type, landing ports, economics/markets, whether targeted/bycatch, other stocks caught in the fishery. Sea cucumbers have been harvested on the coast for hundreds of years. The California fishery is assessed as ‘sea cucumbers’, which includes warty sea cucumbers and California sea cucumbers. Commercial lands were first recorded in Los Angeles in 1978. Combined annual landings for the commercial dive and trawl fisheries remained under 100,000 lbs until 1982, when the fishery expanded to adjacent areas. Initially, trawl landings dominated, but 1997-2002, diver harvest dominated, partly because of prosecution against illegal trawl harvest, and partly because of the collapse of adjacent diver fisheries. There is no significant recreational fishery. Warty sea cucumber are primarily caught by divers. Landings are primarily exported to Hong Kong, Taiwan, mainland China and South Korea; some are retained in California Asian markets as well.

  2. Describe the stock’s ecosystem functions, dependencies, and habitat types. “The California sea cucumber is distributed from Baja California to Alaska. The warty sea cucumber is distributed from Baja California to Monterey Bay, although it is uncommon north of Pt. Conception. The California sea cucumber is found from the low intertidal to 300 feet (91 meters), and the warty sea cucumber is found from the low intertidal to 90 feet (27 meters), generally in areas with little water movement. Sea cucumbers are epibenthic detritivores that feed on organic detritus and small organisms within sediments and muds. Buccal tentacles trap food particles using an adhesive mucus. Sea cucumbers are non-selective with respect to grain size and ingest only the top few millimeters of sediment. One study of warty sea cucumbers around Santa Catalina Island found that those living on rock rubble were 27 percent smaller and seven times more numerous than those residing on sandy substrates. The detritus on rock rubble was found to have three times more organic material per gram compared to the detritus from the sand substrate, and sea cucumbers on the sand ingested eight times more sediment. In a recent study, California sea cucumbers were found to have the highest densities on shell debris, gravel, and boulders, and the lowest on mud and silt bottoms.” (2006 Warty Sea Cucumber Status.pdf)

  3. Provide all relevant reference materials, such as assessments, research, and other analysis. 2006 Stock status: 2006 Sea Cucumber status.pdf Temperate sea cucumber status: Hamel, J.-F.; Mercier, A. 2008. Population status, fisheries and trade of sea cucumbers in temperate areas of the Northern Hemisphere. In V. Toral-Granda, A. Lovatelli and M. Vasconcellos (eds). Sea cucumbers. A global review of fisheries and trade. FAO Fisheries and Aquaculture Technical Paper. No. 516. Rome, FAO. pp. 257-291. (Temperate sea cucumber status.pdf) Continental Sea cucumber status: Bruckner, Andrew W. 2005. The recent status of sea cucumber fisheries in the continental United States of America. SPC Beche-de-mer Information Bulletin #22. (Bruckner 2005.pdf) Sea cucumber 2001 status report: CDFG 2001.pdf


Fishery Characteristics

Longevity

Answered
Very short-lived (5 < maximum age < 7)
Short-lived (7 < maximum age < 10)
Moderate life span (10 < maximum age < 20)
Moderately long-lived (20 < maximum age < 40)
Long-lived (40 < maximum age < 80)
Very long-lived (80 < maximum age < 160)
Justification
Little biological information is known about the warty sea cucumber. This is particularly challenging because you can’t tag them and you can’t age them. Mortality rate is quite unknown.

Stock depletion

Answered
Crashed (D < 0.05)
Very depleted (0.05 < D < 0.1)
Depleted (0.1 < D < 0.15)
Moderately depleted (0.15 < D < 0.3)
Healthy (0.3 < D < 0.5)
Underexploited (0.5 < D)
Justification
“Before–after, control–impact (BACI) analyses of seven fished and two non-fished sites [inside and outside marine reserves] implicated fishing mortality as the cause of 33–83% stock declines.” (Schroeter et al. 2001)

“The Channel Islands National Parks Service has been monitoring warty sea cucumbers at 16 sites in the northern Channel Islands and Santa Barbara Island since 1982 (Figure 5.3). These fishery independent data show that populations of warty sea cucumber are variable but have been declining at fished sites since 1990.
Meanwhile, sea cucumber catches from the dive fishery have increased at some of these sites. Recent analysis comparing population trends at fished sites to those of two small reserves where fishing is prohibited indicate that populations at fished sites range from 50 to more than 80 percent lower than at protected sites.

Fishery independent sea cucumber density estimates have also been made using underwater video technology. Preliminary observations of California sea cucumbers in an established reserve in northern California (Point Cabrillo Marine Protected Area) at depths of 150 to 180 feet (46 to 55 meters) revealed densities averaging around 1,000 per acre (405 per hectare). By comparison, densities at a newly established reserve (Punta Gorda Ecological Reserve) were much lower, ranging from 120 to 350 per acre (49 to 142 per hectare). Only the large size classes were observed in these surveys, suggesting low levels of recruitment.” (2006 Sea Cucumber status.pdf)

Resilence

Answered
Not resilient (steepness < 0.3)
Low resilience (0.3 < steepness < 0.5)
Moderate resilence (0.5 < steepness < 0.7)
Resilient (0.7 < steepness < 0.9)
Very Resilient (0.9 < steepness)
Justification
“Only the large size classes were observed in these surveys, suggesting low levels of recruitment.” (2006 Sea Cucumber status.pdf)

Historical effort pattern

Answered
Stable
Two-phase
Boom-bust
Gradual increases
Stable, recent increases
Stable, recent declines
Justification
Fishing effort (particularly trawl) increased through the 80-90s; several trawl licences were found to be fraudulent and the effort switched to primarily divers. Diving effort rose through shifts from other species. Total catch peaked in 2002. Trawl catch has remained constant, diver effort declined as other species were targeted.

In 1997 a new system was enacted - limited total number of permits and needed separate permits for diving and trawling. Also had permit transfer fees; permits could be transferred from trawl to dive, but couldn’t transfer a dive to trawl. Maximum number of permits has declined as a result; from 113 dive and 36 trawl permits to 92 dive and 20 trawl permitees remaining. (2006 Sea Cucumber Status.pdf)

Inter-annual variability in historical effort

Answered
Not variable (less than 20% inter-annual change (IAC))
Variable (maximum IAC between 20% to 50%)
Highly variable (maximum IAC between 50% and 100%)
Justification
No information on number of sea cucumber permits could be found. Recent permits have been declining.

Historical fishing efficiency changes

Answered
Declining by 2-3% pa (halves every 25-35 years)
Declining by 1-2% pa (halves every 35-70 years)
Stable -1% to 1% pa (may halve/double every 70 years)
Increasing by 1-2% pa (doubles every 35-70 years)
Increasing by 2-3% pa (doubles every 25-35 years)
Justification
Fishing practices have remained stable. The only reason for increase in efficiency would be due to targeting known favourable habitats.

Future fishing efficiency changes

Answered
Declining by 2-3% pa (halves every 25-35 years)
Declining by 1-2% pa (halves every 35-70 years)
Stable -1% to 1% pa (may halve/double every 70 years)
Increasing by 1-2% pa (doubles every 35-70 years)
Increasing by 2-3% pa (doubles every 25-35 years)
Justification
Increased knowledge of habitat preferences of areas and times of aggregation will likely lead to increased efficiency in future

Length at maturity

Answered
Very small (0.4 < LM < 0.5)
Small (0.5 < LM < 0.6)
Moderate (0.6 < LM < 0.7)
Moderate to large (0.7 < LM < 0.8)
Large (0.8 < LM < 0.9)
Justification
“Parastichopus parvimensis does not become sexually mature until it reaches ca. 40 g in total body weight (Muscat, 1983)” - citation from (Population status, fisheries
and trade of sea cucumbers in temperate areas of the Northern Hemisphere)
-Muscat, A.M. 1982. Aspects of the biology of the sea cucumber, Parastichopus parvimensis: a developing commercial fishery (R-RD-14). The Planning and Management of California’s Coastal Resources. USC Sea Grant Institutional Program 1981-82, Trainee Report, University of Southern California, pp. 25–27.

Warty sea cucumbers grow to 30-40 cm (Bruckner 2006)

Selectivity of small fish

Answered
Very small (0.1 < S < 0.2)
Small (0.2 < S < 0.4)
Half asymptotic length (0.4 < S < 0.6)
Large (0.6 < S < 0.8)
Very large (0.8 < S < 0.9)
Justification
No information on captured sizes are given.

Selectivity of large fish

Answered
Asymptotic selectivity (SL = 1)
Declining selectivity with length (0.75 < SL < 1)
Dome-shaped selectivity (0.25 < SL < 0.75)
Strong dome-shaped selectivity (SL < 0.25)
Justification
No information on captured sizes are given.

Discard rate

Answered
Low (DR < 1%)
Low - moderate (1% < DR < 10%)
Moderate (10% < DR < 30%)
Moderate - high (30% < DR < 50%)
High (50% < DR < 70%)
Justification
No information given. These appear to be relatively resilient given they can eviscerate their internal organs and regrow. I presume a released sea cucumber would live fine thereafter.

Post-release mortality rate

Answered
Low (PRM < 5%)
Low - moderate (5% < PRM < 25%)
Moderate (25% < PRM < 50%)
Moderate - high (50% < PRM < 75%)
High (75% < PRM < 95%)
Almost all die (95% < PRM < 100%)
Justification
Catch variability is relatively low and some of this variability will be due to (unknown) effort variation.

Recruitment variability

Answered
Very low (less than 20% inter-annual changes (IAC))
Low (max IAC of between 20% and 60%)
Moderate (max IAC of between 60% and 120%)
High (max IAC of between 120% and 180%)
Very high (max IAC greater than 180%)
Justification
There are marine reserves, but I can’t tell how much of their existing habitat this encompasses.

Size of an existing MPA

Answered
None
Small (A < 5%)
Small-moderate (5% < A < 10%)
Moderate (10% < A < 20%)
Large (20% < A < 30%)
Very large (30% < A < 40%)
Huge (40% < A < 50%)
Justification
Sea cucumbers move an average of 4m per day (although they can increase their movement if attacked).

Spatial mixing (movement) in/out of existing MPA

Answered
Very low (P < 1%)
Low (1% < P < 5%)
Moderate (5% < P < 10%)
High (10% < P < 20%)
Fully mixed
Justification
There are currently marine reserves; there is no plan to remove them.

Size of a future potential MPA

Answered
None
Small (A < 5%)
Small-moderate (5% < A < 10%)
Moderate (10% < A < 20%)
Large (20% < A < 30%)
Very large (30% < A < 40%)
Huge (40% < A < 50%)
Justification
There are currently marine reserves; there is no plan to remove them.

Spatial mixing (movement) in/out of future potential MPA

Answered
Very low (P < 1%)
Low (1% < P < 5%)
Moderate (5% < P < 10%)
High (10% < P < 20%)
Fully mixed
Justification
Sea cucumbers move an average of 4m per day.

Initial stock depletion

Answered
Very low (0.1 < D1 < 0.15)
Low (0.15 < D1 < 0.3)
Moderate (0.3 < D < 0.5)
High (0.5 < D1)
Asymptotic unfished levels (D1 = 1)
Justification
Sea cucumbers have been fished for centuries, but a directed fishery started in 1978. It is assumed that the population was close to unfished at this point.


Management Characteristics

Types of fishery management that are possible

Answered
TAC (Total Allowable Catch): a catch limit
TAE (Total Allowable Effort): an effort limit
Size limit
Time-area closures (a marine reserve)
Justification
1. Describe what, if any, current management measures are used to constrain catch/effort.
There is limited recreational fisheries on warty sea cucumbers. Recreational fishers may not harvest within 1000 feet of the high tide mark and are limited to 35 per day.
Only commercial permitees may participate and trawl fisheries generally avoid warty sea cucumbers. As of 2006, there were only 92 dive permitees (and 20 trawl licences).

2. Describe historical management measures, if any.
“1992 Section 8396; Fish and Game Code. Required fishermen to obtain a sea cucumber permit, issued to fishermen based on a qualifying minimum 50 lb landing of sea cucumbers made between 01/01/1988 and 06/30/1991
1994 Section 8396, Fish and Game Code, amended. Allowed some trawl fishermen to obtain sea cucumber permits on appeal, without having to meet the minimum landing requirement. Specified that sea cucumber permits were non-transferable and established a $250 annual permit fee.
1997 Section 8407, Fish and Game Code. Repealed section 8396 of the Fish and Game Code; instituted separate trawl and dive sea cucumber permits; set up a permit transfer mechanism, and set a ceiling of trawl and dive permittees allowed in the fishery, based on the number of permits issued during the 1997-98 license year.” (2006 Sea Cucumber Status.pdf)

3. Describe main strengths and weaknesses of current monitoring and enforcement capacity.
Little information on catch monitoring could be found. Population status is monitored using ROV surveys in and outside of marine reserves in the area. This provides a rough index of depletion, assuming minimal exchange between areas.

4. Describe and reference any legal/policy requirements for management, monitoring and enforcement.


TAC offset: consistent overages/underages

Answered
Large underages (40% - 70% of recommended)
Underages (70% - 90% of recommended)
Slight underages (90% - 100% of recommended)
Taken exactly (95% - 105% of recommended)
Slight overages (100% - 110% of recommended)
Overages (110% - 150% of recommended)
Large overages (150% - 200% of recommended)
Justification
No TAC


TAC implementation variability

Answered
Constant (V < 1%)
Not variable (1% < V < 5%)
Low variability (5% < V < 10%)
Variable (10% < V < 20%)
Highly variable (20% < V < 40%)
Justification
No TAC


TAE offset: consistent overages/underages

Answered
Large underages (40% - 70% of recommended)
Underages (70% - 90% of recommended)
Slight underages (90% - 100% of recommended)
Taken exactly (95% - 105% of recommended)
Slight overages (100% - 110% of recommended)
Overages (110% - 150% of recommended)
Large overages (150% - 200% of recommended)
Justification
TAE is only based on permits issued; so no overages/underages


TAE implementation variability

Answered
Constant (V < 1%)
Not variable (1% < V < 5%)
Low variability (5% < V < 10%)
Variable (10% < V < 20%)
Highly variable (20% < V < 40%)
Justification
Total number of permits has been declining in recent years (2006 Sea Cucumber Status.pdf)


Size limit offset: consistent overages/underages

Answered
Much smaller (40% - 70% of recommended)
Smaller (70% - 90% of recommended)
Slightly smaller (90% - 100% of recommended)
Taken exactly (95% - 105% of recommended)
Slightly larger (100% - 110% of recommended)
Larger (110% - 150% of recommended)
Much larger (150% - 200% of recommended)
Justification
No size limits


Size limit implementation variability

Answered
Constant (V < 1%)
Not variable (1% < V < 5%)
Low variability (5% < V < 10%)
Variable (10% < V < 20%)
Highly variable (20% < V < 40%)
Justification
No size limits


Data Characteristics

Available data types

Answered
Historical annual catches (from unfished)
Recent annual catches (at least 5 recent years)
Historical relative abundance index (from unfished)
Recent relative abundance index (at least 5 recent years)
Fishing effort
Size composition (length samples)
Age composition (age samples)
Growth (growth parameters)
Absolute biomass survey
Justification
1. Provide the time series (specify years, if possible) that exist for catch, effort, and CPUE/abundance indices.
Catch data exist from the start of the fishery (see Landings.png, which shows landings for California and Warty Sea Cucumber combined)
Divers used transects to estimate density inside and outside the fished areas exist since 1982 (see Relative Abundance.png)
Fishery independent dive estimates are also available from ROV - this may only be for California Sea Cucumbers.

2. Describe how these data collected (e.g., log books, dealer reporting, observers).
Catch data are from reported landings
Relative density estimates are collected from ROV surveys at 16 specific monitoring sites in and out of marine protected areas.

3. Describe what types of sampling programs and methodologies exist for data collection, including the time-series of available sampling data and quality.
Landings:
“The data are based on landings weighed at the dock by the processor, who re- cords the data on a “fish ticket” which is given to the CDFG. Fish- ermen are required to assign their landings to 10 × 10 nautical mile fish blocks and report the fishing effort (i.e., number of boat days) allocated to their catch." (Schroeter et al. 2001)

4. Describe all sources of uncertainty in the status, biology, life history and data sources of the fishery. Include links to documentation, reports.
Density inside and outside marine reserves: Schroeter et al. 2001
biological and population status: 2006 Sea Cucumber Status.pdf


Catch reporting bias

Answered
Strong under-reporting (30% - 50%)
Under-reporting (10% - 30%)
Slight under-reporting (0% - 10%)
Reported accurately (+/- 5%)
Slight over-reporting (less than 10%)
Justification
No information is provided. Catch estimates are obtained from logbook reporting. There have been illegal trawling in the past, but it is presumed that is no longer a problem.


Hyperstability in indices

Answered
Strong hyperdepletion (2 < Beta < 3)
Hyperdepletion (1.25 < Beta < 2)
Proportional (0.8 < Beta < 1.25)
Hyperstability (0.5 < Beta < 0.8)
Strong hyperstability (0.33 < Beta < 0.5)
Justification
“Before–after, control–impact (BACI) analyses of seven fished and two non-fished sites implicated fishing mortality as the cause of 33–83% stock declines. In sharp contrast, stock assessment based on CPUE data showed no declines and a significant increase at one island.” (Schroeter et al. 2001)


Available data types

Answered
Perfect
Good (accurate and precise)
Data moderate (some what inaccurate and imprecise)
Data poor (inaccurate and imprecise)
Justification
While catch information is available, CPUE data is unreliable due to hyperstability (warty sea cucumbers aggregate at certain times of year, presumably associated with spawning). There is some fishery-independent data, but no stock assessment yet. Biological data are spotty - no mortality estimate, no growth rates or age at maturity, no selectivity information.


Version Notes

The package is subject to ongoing testing. If you find a bug or a problem please send a report to so that it can be fixed!




tcar_-2019-11-26-10:25:40

Open Source, GPL-2 2019